Status
|
Construction scheme
(future) |
Where
|
Construction
of a new motorway flyover link directly
between the M1 in the Belfast direction
and the A1, and the provision of a
new grade separated junction serving
Hillsborough. |
Total
Length
|
Approx 3.0km -
5.0km depending on route
|
Dates
|
First proposed July
2006
Scheme given go-ahead
April 2008
Stage 1 assessment
report published March 2012
Scheme put on hold - as of Sep 2016
(Construction had
been expected by 2018 as of Nov 2010)
Scheme confirmed to be on hold - Aug
2023
|
Cost
|
£85m - £104m
depending on route (as of Mar 2012)
changed
from £45m (as of 2006) |
|
See maps below
No photos as yet -
please contact me if you have any to
contribute.
|
See
Also
|
General
area map - Google Maps
Stage
1 Assessment Report (Mar 2012) -
Roads Service
|
Click here to jump straight
down to updates for this scheme.
It has been a common complaint that the main
route on the island of Ireland, Belfast to
Dublin, involves traffic leaving Belfast along
the M1 and then going off at a sliproad, and
crawling round two roundabouts before continuing
on the A1 dual-carriageway towards Newry and
Dublin. The current arrangement uses two related
junctions (7 and 8) at Sprucefield which also
serves the western end of Lisburn city, a major
shopping centre and (since 2004) a large retail
park. This scheme will see a bypass constructed
to give freeflow access between the A1 and M1
(east).
Two route corridors have been under
consideration. These are shown on the map below.
It is important to stress that these lines
indicate the centres of general route
corridors which extend for a few
hundred metres on either side of the line shown.
They are not
final routes. Please do not be alarmed if your
property lies on or close to the line itself.
The Culcavy
East route corridor is shown in blue,
and the Central
route corridor is shown in red. The purple line
is the old 2006 route corridor that is no longer
being actively considered. You scan see how the
scheme design has advanced in scale since 2006.
View M1 A1
Sprucefield Bypass in a larger map
The next stage in the process will be to refine
the design of these two options and then pick one.
Here are some relevant statistics for the two
corridors, taken from the March 2012 Stage 1
report:
|
CULCAVY EAST
|
CENTRAL
|
Approximate
Length of new road
|
3.0 km
|
4.5 - 5.0
km
|
Estimated
construction cost
|
£102 -
£104m
|
£84.7m -
£88.7m |
30 year
Cost/Benefit ratio (>1 means
beneficial)
|
1.01 - 1.02
|
1.43 - 1.53
|
The scheme appears to be being designed
specifically to prevent local traffic using the
new stretch of road. This will be achieved by
allowing traffic to enter the new stretch only
from the M1 (east) or A1 (south), but NOT from
Lisburn, the M1 (west) or local traffic from
Culcavy and Hillsborough. All of this traffic will
have to use the existing section of A1 between
Hillsborough and Sprucefield, which would not be
an issue given that traffic levels here would fall
very dramatically once the new link opens.
Note that, because it leads inevitably onto the
M1, the new link road legally MUST be a motorway
too, at least northbound from the last available
exit. Whether it will be signed as a motorway with
blue signs, or merely be a legal but unsigned
'secret' motorway, is not yet known. The other
interesting point is that the Culcavy East
corridor joins the M1 at the existing junction 8.
To avoid weaving (cars trying to change lanes from
left to right while others are trying to change
from right to left), this would require the
construction of braided sliproads (sliproads which
cross each other). There are plenty
of these in Great Britain, but none
currently in Northern Ireland.
History of Scheme
The scheme was outlined in the Belfast
Metropolitan Area Plan of 2006. The map below (based
on the land protection corridor outlined in
the BMAP Plan Amendment Number One, 2006)
showed an indicative layout. A road protection
corridor was put in place so that this 4.0 km /
2.5 mile route could be built. The cost at that
point was estimated at £45m. The scheme was
given the formal go-ahead in the document
"Investment Delivery Plan for Roads" published
in April 2008.
Proposed link at Sprucefield
(shown in purple) as of 2006.
This option is no longer under consideration.
Updates
1 Nov 2023: Seven years since the last
update, this update is simply to confirm that
literally nothing has happened since this scheme
was effectively paused in 2015/16. In the summer
DFI Roads released
a document showing how the current roads
programme will be prioritised in the current
economic and legislative climate. The document
confirms that work on the Sprucefield Bypass
"paused", though this is not a change, as it had
already been paused anyway. The next concrete
thing to happen will be the publication of DFI's
new Transport Plan, expected in the next year or
so. This plan will determine whether this scheme
is still being considered. This will depend not
simply on the availability of money (of course,
there isn't any!), but the whole policy
direction of transport going forward,
particularly with the 2022 law change that now
requires DFI to de-carbonise transport. I have
been contacted every so often by landowners who
might be affected by the scheme, so it would be
good for them to know either way to avoid
decades of property blight.
22 Sep 2016: In my last update two years
ago I noted that insufficient funding had been
made available to continue development work into
2015, and this situation seems to be continuing.
The Department for Infrastructure web page about
this scheme was last updated in June 2016 and
now says "Due to current budget restrictions
there is insufficient funding to allow
development work to continue. Progression of
the scheme beyond this period will be subject
to future budget settlements". That means
nothing whatsoever has happened on this scheme
since around 2012 and nothing further seems to
be planned in the foreseeable future. So this
scheme is effectively parked and is now sitting
well and truly in the "would be nice" pile,
hopefully to be picked up at some point in the
years ahead. A big change from 2010 when we were
told the road would be constructed by 2018. What
a difference a recession makes.
16 Aug 2014: The DRD
web page on this scheme is now saying "Due
to current budget restrictions there is
insufficient funding to allow development work
to continue during this financial year, and it
is anticipated to remain the case until the
end of the 2015 budget period. Progression of
the scheme beyond this period will be subject
to available funding." The statement is
not dated, so it's not clear what "this
financial year" refers to, or whether "the end
of the 2015 budget period" means April 2015 or
April 2016, but either way the bottom line is
that nothing is currently happening on this
scheme which seems to now be a bit down the list
of priorities within Transport NI (the new name
for Roads Service). I doubt if we'll see much
news about this scheme for the next two or three
years, so in the meantime keep enjoying the only
remaining set of roundabouts between Belfast and
Dublin. Honk honk!
5 Nov 2012: The traffic problems
experienced at the Hillsborough roundabout on
the A1 were the subject of an adjournment
debate in Stormont a fortnight ago. This
gave the "roads" Minister the opportunity to
update us on this scheme. He did not say much
that we do not know, except to comment that
Roads Service are giving consideration to
signalising the Hillsborough roundabout due to
the extensive queues that form here at peak
times. He noted that a previous signalisation
scheme was cancelled due to "limited support
for the scheme among the various
representatives". He also said that a
free-flow "jet lane" for northbound traffic was
ruled out as being unsafe due to adjacent
private accesses off the A1. He once again
committed to the Sprucefield Bypass, but noting
that it was still a future plan with no funding
currently identified to build it.
5 April 2012: The Stage 1
report was published
last month, albeit without any of the
associated maps and diagrams. This document
shows that the consultants looked at seven
possible route corridors (click
for map). One of these is the original
2006 route corridor. However it's clear that the
scope of the scheme has grown in ambition. Of
the seven corridors, two have been taken forward
- the "Culcavy East" corridor passing close to
Culcavy, and a "Central" corridor following a
smoother, more sweeping version of the 2006
corridor. I have shown these corridors on the
Google map above. Both corridors depart from the
A1 south of the Hillsborough Roundabout. It's
fairly safe to say, therefore, that grade
separating Hillsborough Roundabout is no longer part of
the scheme. What will probably happen
instead is that there will be a new junction for
Hillsborough (probably with south-facing
sliproads only), but the old roundabout will
remain in-situ, demoted to the use of local
traffic. Both options tie in to the existing M1
with east-facing sliproads only, meaning that
the existing A1 will also have to remain in use
for traffic coming from the M1 (west) and from
Lisburn. The costs of the two options are given
as £104m for Culcavy East and £85m for the
Central corridor, both of which are well in
excess of the £45m figure given back in 2006,
although that was for a much shorter scheme. The
Central corridor gives the best 30 year
cost/benefit ratio (1.48 compared to 1.02 for
Culcavy East). Anything above 1 means that the
scheme will bring more benefits than costs, so
this implies that the Culcavy East corridor
would just about break even, but the Central
corridor would be more beneficial overall. In
terms of construction, the official line is
still "by 2018", but given the number of
competing schemes and general lack of money I
would regard this as very unlikely.
30 Jan 2011: According to a written
question in the Northern Ireland Assembly
on 17 December 2010, the consultants that Roads
Service appointed in early 2009 (see previous
update) are still working on the scheme and will
publish a Stage 1 Report "early next year". The
Stage 1 Report will outline the route corridors
within which further options will be considered.
Given that this work has already been
ongoing for almost two years, this suggests that
there is no particular urgency with this scheme.
Indeed, the recent budget cuts mean that it is
unlikely to be constructed in the foreseeable
future anyway. The Minister is currently giving
construction "between 2014 and 2018", but I
would be surprised if work is underway even by
2018.
29 Aug 2009: According to
Roads Service's report
to Lisburn City Council in June 2009, they
have now appointed Scott Wilson as consultants
to develop proposals for this scheme. It should
be noted that the scheme may not follow the
"road protection corridor" that I used for my
mockup maps above, so could be completely
different. The say: "The commission will
require the consideration of a range of
options and an evaluation of all of the viable
options available for capacity enhancement
along this route. Proposals would take account
of future development proposals in the area
and any detailed proposals developed for the
road improvement would be subject to public
scrutiny through the normal statutory
processes."
12 Jan 2009: Roads Service issued
a leaflet about the scheme in November.
The leaflet doesn't really say anything new, but
it does confirm Roads Service's committment to
the scheme and suggests that the BMAP "road
protection corridor" that is used for the maps
above still seems to be valid. The leaflet
estimates that the scheme will be completed
during the period 2014-2018.
|