Status
|
Construction scheme
(ongoing - 3 complete; 0 ongoing; 4
still to do) |
Where
|
To
provide a number of individual
improvements to the A32 to improve
access to the new regional hospital in
Enniskillen. |
Total
Length
|
Series of
individual schemes - total length
unknown |
Dates
|
Scheme first proposed
- July 2006
Scheme given go-ahead
- April 2008
See table below for
progress on individual elements
All schemes were
originally to proceed by 2015 (as of Nov
2008)
Only 3 schemes completed as of Aug 2021
All but 1 of the remaining schemes
(Cornamuck) "paused" - Aug 2023
|
Cost
|
Total cost will be in
the ballpark of £30m as of 2023
Originally £10m from the Dept of
Regional Development (as of 2008) plus
£5m from the Dept of
Health, Social Services and Public
Safety (as of 2009)
|
Photos
|
See below |
See
Also
|
General
area map
|
Click
here to jump straight down to updates
for this scheme.
The A32 is the principle route between Omagh
and Enniskillen and passes through the towns of
Dromore and Irvinestown. Now that there is a
plan to replace the acute functions of Omagh's
Tyrone County Hospital and Enniskillen's Erne
Hospital with a new hospital to the north of
Enniskillen, the government has planned a series
of seven improvement schemes for the A32. The
work is taking place over a period of years. As
of June 2015 three schemes are completed, and
four more are planned.
The process began in 2007 when Roads Service
Western Division carried out a review of the A32
between Omagh and Enniskillen and made a list of
15 potential schemes. In 2008 these were
whittled down to 9. Two of these - Sidaire and
Drumbulcan - were subsequently dropped, giving a
final total of 7 schemes.
The upgrades consist
of the following (colours give a broad
indication of progress):
Scheme Name |
Work |
Location |
Progress
(as of Aug 2023) |
Mullaghbane |
Realignment and widening over 0.7 km
Contractor: James Balfour &
Sons Ltd
|
Between Omagh and Dromore |
Contract
awarded Dec 2008
Work carried out between Jan 2009 and mid
2009 |
Shannaragh |
2.2 km off-line realignment £7.3m
Contractor: Coffey
Construction/White Mountain joint venture
|
Between Omagh and Dromore |
Design
work began 2009
Main contract awarded Jan 2012. Work began
5 Mar 2012. Officially opened 13 Feb 2013
(ahead of Mar 2013 due date).
|
Drumskinny |
1.1 km online widening £1.8m
Contractor: Fox Building &
Engineering Ltd
|
Between Dromore and Irvinestown |
Advanced
site works took place early 2010. Main
contract began Sep 2011. Completed Mar
2012.
|
Esker Bog |
1.1 km
off-line realignment
£3.0m
|
immediately
west of Dromore town |
Stage 1 report approved
13 March 2012.
Stage 2 report approved 27 Feb 2013.
Scheme "paused" as of Aug 2023
|
Cornamuck |
1.5 km off-line realignment
£8.6m as of Dec 2023 (was £6m as of Mar
2016) |
Between Dromore and Irvinestown |
Stage 2
report approved 13 Mar 2012.
Vesting Order "made" 8 Feb 2017. Site
clearance took place - Mar 2018. Awaiting
funding and inclusion in future transport
plans
|
New Park |
1.3 km off-line realignment |
Between Dromore and Irvinestown |
Missing
in action – presumed to be "paused" as of
Aug 2023
|
Kilgortnaleague |
2 km off-line realignment and widening
£7m |
Between Irvinestown and Enniskillen |
Preferred
route identified by 2022, but never
published. Flood Risk Assessment report
approved April 2019. Scheme "paused" as of
Aug 2023 |
The map below shows
the location of all but the first of these
schemes (Sidaire was subsequently abandoned).
Photos
These
are all links to Google Streetview.
Updates
13 Dec 2023: In their most recent report
to Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, DFI
provided an update on the Cornamuck
scheme, the only outstanding element of the
project that is not officially "paused" (more on
that in a minute). Firstly, the cost has risen
quite sharply from £6m (as of 2016) to £8.6m,
probably reflecting the impact of construction
inflation. Secondly, the report notes that "Preparation
of the contract documents is underway".
However, it then goes on to say that "A
future decision on the delivery of the scheme
will be taken once Department’s emerging
transport policies and transport plans have
been developed to a sufficient stage". So,
while the tender documents are being produced,
it is clearly not going to get funding or
proceed to tender if it's contingent on plans
that are not yet published, albeit plans that
are expected in the not-too-distant future. So,
while some work is technically happening on the
tender documents, I would now regard the scheme
as being de facto on hold. In the
meantime, you can pass the time playing "spot
the vested land" on Google
Maps!
18 Aug 2023: DFI Roads this week
released a document showing how the current
roads programme will be prioritised in the
current economic and legislative climate, where
DFI is now required to de-carbonise transport.
Only the Cornamuck scheme has made the
cut, with Esker Bog and Kilgortnaleague
now officially paused. Whether they ever happen
will now depend on the new transport plans being
developed by DFI and the local councils. This
might be why DFI never published the preferred
route for Kilgortnaleage that they had
identified by 2021. Nothing whatsoever was said
about the New Park scheme in the most
recent announcement, a scheme which has been
missing in action now for years, even though
it's still
listed on DFI's web site, so I am going to
assume the same applies to it. Despite making
the cut and remaining on the current roads
programme, Cornamuck does not have any funding
allocation and DFI admit that there is no
current likely source for funding either. DFI
will also not proceed with this scheme until the
new transport plans are out, though they are
continuing to work to put it to tender should
funding become available. This is a shame as the
approx £6m cost for Cornamuck is peanuts
compared to big schemes like the £1600m A5
scheme. The land for Cornamuck was vested six
years ago now (a fact that can be seen
from space!) and all design work is
complete.
10 Mar 2023: In the annual
report to Fermanagh and Omagh District
Council two weeks ago, DFI mentioned the Kilgortnaleague
scheme (between Enniskillen and Irvinestown, not
far from the airport). The report says that “Design
work on the Kilgortnaleague realignment,
between Irvinestown and Enniskillen, has also
progressed and a Preferred Corridor has been
identified.” Given that this was also the
position in the 2022 annual report, and the 2021
annual report before that, I think we can
conclude that not a lot is happening on this
scheme. The Investment Strategy for Northern
Ireland currently lists the scheme as to go out
to tender in June 2025, but I honestly think
this is a finger-in-the-air date that doesn’t
really mean anything. The last cost estimate of
£7m was seven years ago, but nevertheless
schemes like this are peanuts compared to major
road schemes so it would be a shame if a lack of
budget continued to prevent it being
implemented. First in the queue is the Cornamuck
scheme which is shovel-ready and just needs
funding.
8 Feb 2023: I still have some hope that
the Cornamuck scheme might happen before too
long. It has passed all the legal hurdles and
just needs cash, and a contractor to be
appointed. Despite budgetary pressures, DFI
recently gave political parties here access to
what it was aiming to progress this year, and
preparing the tender documents for the A32
Cornamuck scheme tender was listed, as directed
by the former minister back in August. The
scheme has a tiny cost (£6m) compared to some
other major road schemes so I would be hopeful
that it can go ahead even if larger projects get
pushed back. A serious collision on this stretch
of the A32 last summer has focused local minds
on how worthwhile it is. There is still no word
on the status of the associated Kilgortnaleague
and Esker Bog schemes. Local
representatives may wish to ask DFI what the
status of these two schemes is, as I have heard
nothing on either for several years.
24 Aug 2022: In a press
release earlier this month, the new DFI
Minister announced that he has instructed his
staff to prepare the tender documents for the
Cornamuck scheme "as a priority during
2022/23". The scheme has been shovel-ready
now for 5 years and just needs funding. This is
a good sign that the Minister regards the scheme
as important, though it does not have a funding
allocation and it's unclear if funding can be
allocated in the absence of an Executive, even
with the senior civil servant taking over
finances today. The last cost estimate was in
2016, at which point it was £6m. While this will
certainly have gone up, the scheme is peanuts
compared to other schemes so in theory should
not be hard to squeeze in.
8 July 2022: It is now 16 years since
this set of schemes was first proposed, and the
Minister was recently
asked for an update on progress. He said
first of all that to date DFI "has delivered two
schemes" (though it has actually provided three;
see table above). He confirmed that the Cornamuck
scheme remains shovel ready, the land having
been vested five years ago. He also commented
that the "preferred route" has now been
determined for Kilgortnaleague, which is
slightly more advanced than the position a year
ago suggesting some work is actually ongoing. As
usual, though, there is no funding to proceed
with either scheme which will probably remain at
this state for the time being.
25 Jul 2021: DFI gave an update on this
embarrassingly sluggish set of schemes in their
recent
report to Fermanagh and Omagh District
Council. Firstly, with reference to the Cornamuck
scheme, for which the land was vested four years
ago, it "is now fully developed and subject
to the necessary funding approvals, is in a
position to progress to procurement and
construction". So all they need is cash
from the Executive, which is in the region of
£6m, a drop in the ocean in terms of strategic
road improvements. Hopefully this will
materialise soon. Secondly, with reference to
the Kilgortnaleague scheme, DFI say that
"a Preferred Corridor has been identified.
Alignment options within the Preferred
Corridor are currently being developed for
consultation." However this has been the
case since 2015, so doesn't suggest that much is
going on. However it does add that "The Flood
Risk Assessment Report was approved by DfI
Rivers in April 2019" which is new
information. Finally, by stating that the above
two schemes are the ones in planning, the report
implies that no further schemes are being
progressed, which suggests that the Esker
Bog scheme (which passed its second stage
report eight years ago in 2013 but has not been
heard from since) and the New Park
scheme may have been abandoned.
30 Dec 2020: DFI recently indicated the
level of priority for various schemes, and the
A32 scheme at Cornamuck was given a
"high priority" rank, alongside the Enniskillen,
Ballynahinch and Cookstown bypasses. DFI have
asked the Dept of Finance for £140,000 for the
scheme for the next financial year which is
certainly not enough to build it, but would be
enough to progress it towards final design and
procurement. The total cost of the scheme
(including the land acquisition which happened
three years ago) is £6m. So that suggests to me
that construction work on the scheme will NOT be
going ahead before April 2022 at the earliest.
That said, the Investment
Strategy for Northern Ireland web site
suggests that the scheme is planned to go out to
tender around June 2021, with a contractor to be
appointed by spring 2022 and work to commence in
June 2022. These ISNI timings have a tendency to
repeatedly slip (compare with the update below
from Jan 2020 to see what I mean), so I would
not read too much certainty into these
timescales, but it does at least give us some
hope that it might happen in the next few years.
Meanwhile, we have heard absolutely nothing
about the other un-built elements of the A32
plans since 2017. Kilgortnaleague is
apparently STILL in planning, and has not even
made it onto DFI's funding bid for next year.
Nothing has been said in the past few years
about Esker Bog or New Park
either.
25 Sep 2020: In a recent
report to Fermanagh and Omagh District
Council DFI said that "The scheme at
Cornamuck is now fully developed and subject
to the necessary funding approvals, is in a
position to progress to procurement and
construction next year", so still no work
imminent despite the Vesting Order having been
made over three years ago. There was a flurry of
work on these A32 schemes about ten years ago,
when three schemes were provided, but since then
no more construction has happened, despite them
being very low cost compared to the flagship
schemes. It appears that the A32 schemes are now
considered a low priority by those with the
purse strings.
12 Jun 2020: The DFI Minister announced
her budget
for the next year, which allocated money to the
Executive's flagship projects (A5, A6 and
Belfast Transport Hub) but did not give any
funding for any other capital road schemes,
including further work on the A32. However she
followed this up today with a press
release clarifying that she had approved
funding for the continuation of planning of
several planned road schemes, including the Cornamuck
element of the A32 project. This is a very cheap
scheme as road projects go, so I would be
hopeful that it will commence soon, albeit not
in the current financial year. As we know, the
Vesting Order was "made" over 3 years ago.
7 Jan 2020: It's now almost three years
since DFI "made" the Vesting Order for the Cornamuck
scheme. It did not go out to tender in 2019 as
anticpated last April. The Investment Strategy
for Northern Ireland web
site is now saying that it will go out to
tender in mid 2020, with construction to get
underway in spring 2021. However, since this
date seems to be constantly shifting into the
future, I am skeptical about how serious this
date is. It seems more likely that the scheme
has no money - perhaps due to the lack of an
Executive - and is getting repeatedly shifted
into the future for want of having anything else
to say about it. This is supported by the most
recent report
to Fermanagh and Omagh District Council (Sep
2019) which merely said that "the opportunity
for funding over the next 2-3 years is
currently being considered". A restoration
of Stormont might be enough to release funds for
what is a very cheap scheme as road schemes go
(£4-6m).
7 Apr 2019: It's now over two years
since DFI "made" the Vesting Order to acquire
the land for the Cornamuck scheme, and
there is still no sign of work getting underway.
The Investment
Strategy for Northern Ireland Pipeline had
been tweaked to now suggest that the scheme
woudl go out to tender in March 2019, but that
date has also come and gone. The only
explanantion that I can see is that the scheme
has not got funding to proceed to construction.
It may be possible for a senior civil servant to
approve it with the powers that they now have in
the absence of a Minister - at £4-6m it's a very
cheap scheme compared to others. I have not been
in the area for some time - if anyone who uses
the road can tell me if there's any indication
of work, eg tree felling, please let me know!
roads at wesleyjohnston dot com.
23 Jun 2018: This continues to be one of
the most painfully slow multi-component schemes
on the road network, as we approach the tenth
annniversary of completion of the first element
(Mullaghbane). We've been awaiting the Cornamuck
scheme, whose Vesting Order was "made" over a
year ago, apparently in the hope of funding
becoming available. Some vegetation clearance
and archaeology DID take place during the spring
(see photo below) but there is still no sign of
the main contract. The Investment
Strategy for Northern Ireland Pipeline
contains an entry suggesting that this scheme is
finally to go out to tender in December this
year (2018) with a total project cost of £4-6m.
The information goes on to suggest a contractor
would be appointed by March 2019 with
construction taking place between June 2019 and
June 2020. It's worth commenting that without a
functioning Executive it's hard to put much
certainty in this sort of thing. The Pipeline
also suggests that the next element, Kilgortnaleague,
is going to be "after 2020". We're also still
awaiting the "preferred corridor" for this
scheme, which was to have been published in
2015.
Vegetation clearance underway on the A32 at
Cornamuck sometime in the spring of 2018 [DFI
image from here]
22 Mar 2018: Vegetation clearance work
appears to have been taking place in the past
few weeks at Cornamuck. The Vesting
Order (that gives the land needed to DFI) was
made a year ago. Tree felling and hedge removal
has to take place before the bird nesting season
begins, so this work implies that DFI want to
begin construction work on this scheme before
the autumn. I don't see any evidence of a
construction tender on the DFI web site, so
either it hasn't been issued yet, or else this
scheme is too small in scale to warrant that
process. With thanks to Owen Brannigan for
spotting this development. There are 7 schemes
in total in this programme, and so far work has
been underway for 9 years, with only 3 built. At
this rate it will take two decades to complete
all 7, which isn't a great record for a set of
schemes that were originally justified by the
need to get quickly from Omagh to the new South
West Acut Hospital in Enniskillen, which has now
been open for 5 years. There is no word on
progress on the other 3 future schemes.
26 Feb 2017: The DFI unexpectedly
"made" the Vesting Order for the Cornamuck
scheme on 8 February. You can see the Vesting
Order map here.
A Vesting Order is a legal document that compels
landowners to sell the land needed for the road.
It exists in a Draft form for many months to
allow all those affected to respond and make
plans, and eventually is activated, or "made",
which is the point at which title in the land
actually changes hands to the DFI. That is what
has now happened. The DFI previously said of the
Cornamuck scheme that "The Vesting Order will
be made when funding for the works becomes
available." So that suggests that this
scheme, the fourth of the seven planned for the
A32, has now got funding. With the other
necessary legal orders published in March 2016,
and Vesting Order now made, and the money in
place, there's really no reason why work cannot
commence. No construction tender has appeared on
the DFI web site, but it is possible that the
scheme may have a low enough cost that it
doesn't need to go through such a process, and
could instead be built by one of DFI's "term
contractors". We will have to wait and see what
happens on the ground in the coming weeks. If
anyone reading this happens to drive along the
A32, perhaps you could let me know if you see
any evidence of work at Cornamuck (which is a
couple of miles west of Dromore)!
19 Oct 2016: In a Written
Answer in the Assembly in July (AQW
2019/16-21) the DfI Minister gave an update on
this scheme. He reiterated that the legal orders
for the Cornamuck scheme had been
published in March, before going on to say "This
has placed this scheme in good position for
delivery in the event that funding becomes
available". That's not a particularly
encouraging statement, as it basically means
there is no money to proceed to construction, at
least up to the end of the current financial
year in March 2017. The Cornamuck scheme is
estimated to cost about £6m. He then went on to
mention Kilgortnaleague and said that "the
uncertainty with regards to availability of
funding, it is not intended to progress this
scheme through the statutory consultation
process at present given that the Cornamuck
scheme is in position to take forward to
delivery". What this means is that since
there is no money to build Cornamuck, there's
hardly any point in progressing Kilgortnaleague
at the same time since it's even less likely
that both will be able to proceed in the
near future. In an oral question in the
Assembly on 4 October the Minister added
that "It is hoped that Transport NI will be
in a position to identify the preferred
alignment for [Kilgortnaleague] in 2017"
at a cost of about £7m, a slight increase on the
£6m figure given previously (It is worth reading
Hansard for the brutally honest answer the
Minister gave when asked if he would divert cash
from the delayed A5 scheme to the A32!).
Finally, the DFI's web site continues
to list the "Sidaire" scheme (along with New
Park and Esker Bog) as "dependent
upon funding", even though the DRD said that the
Sidaire scheme had been cancelled almost six
years ago (see update for December 2010 below)
due to escalating costs. So, all in all, not
looking particularly hopeful for further work on
the A32 in the near future.
13 Mar 2016: The DRD Minister announced
the publication of two of the three legal orders
needed for the Cornamuck scheme on 1
March. These are the Direction Order (which
formally gives the DRD permission to construct a
new trunk road) and the Notice
of Intention to Proceed (whereby the DRD
explains what they are going to do and why they
think it's worth doing). What has not been
published is the Vesting Order (which compels
landowners to seel the necessary land to the
DRD). This final legal order is usually only
made when money has been allocated and
construction is likely to get underway soon,
because it requires the DRD to spend money
buying land. The fact that they have not
published the Vesting Order shows us that there
is currently no funding to actually build the
Cornamuck scheme. The publication of these two
documents does move the scheme a little closer
towards construction, but not by much since a
cash allocation is the main thing that is needed
to progress it. The scheme is now estimated to
cost £6m, an increase on the £5m being quoted in
December 2014. We are now almost ten years since
this suite of schemes on the A32 was first
proposed in 2006. To date three have been
completed, and four remain unbuilt.
9 Nov 2015: The DRD has now put all the
documents and maps relating to the recent
consultation on the proposed Cornamuck
scheme on their web site here.
A public consultation period seems to have taken
place from 26 August to 16 October, though I
missed this at the time. In addition, the DRD
web site now notes that TNI Design and
Consultancy Services and its partner Amey are
the appointed consultants to develop the Stage 1
and Stage 2 reports for the Kilgortnaleague
scheme, as referred to in the June update
(below). There is still no indication of any of
the four remaining schemes being taken to
construction - it's now almost three years since
any work took place on the A32 on the ground.
Interestingly the DRD's web site lists the
"Sidaire" scheme (along with New Park
and Esker Bog) as "dependent upon
funding", even though the DRD said that the
Sidaire scheme had been cancelled almost five
years ago (see update for December 2010 below)
due to escalating costs. So this information is
either spectacularly out of date, or else the
scheme has been resurrected. The fact that it
appears on a recently-produced map on the DRD
web site suggests that the latter is a
possibility. We will have to watch and see if
anything happens.
5 Jul 2015: Thanks to a very helpful
chap at TransportNI, I have just become aware
that a public consultation event into the
proposed realignment at Cornamuck took place in
December 2014. This was kept very quiet as I can
find no reference to it on the Internet!
However, the leaflet that was given out shows
that what is proposed is basically a slicing off
of the
bad curve at Cornamuck by creating a new
straight road between either end. Longhill Road,
which will be cut in two by the new alignment,
will be connected to the new road by a pair of
staggered T-junctions. The "old" A32 will become
a pair of cul-de-sacs accessible only from
Longhill Road.
10 Jun 2015: The DRD
web site was updated a week ago with a
comment about the Kilgortnaleague
scheme. It now says "Working to complete
Stage 1 and 2 reports during 2015/16."
These reports are what will result in a
preferred route alignment for the 2km scheme
that can then proceed to tender. Depending on
how the contract is worded the contractor may be
responsible for detailed design, or TransportNI
may do this in-house, leaving the contractor to
purely construct it. The timescale given is not
as hopeful as was the case in December, with the
implication that the announcement of a preferred
corridor might drift into 2016. In December the
Minister also indicated that the draft legal
orders for Cornamuck would be published
in March 2015 - it's possible I have missed
them, but I don't think they have been. As far
as actual construction goes, is also worth
noting that the Stage 2 reports for the Cornamuck
and Esker Bog schemes were completed in
2012 and 2013 respectively, and they have not
yet even proceeded to tender. This suite of
schemes has now been under construction since
December 2008, and so far 3 of the 7 have been
completed. The table further up this page
summarises the various schemes.
18 Dec 2014: The Minister was
asked about progress on this set of schemes in
the Assembly last week and he provided an
update. To recap, three of the seven schemes are
now complete with four still to be carried out.
The table at the top of this page provides a
summary of the current position. Firstly, he
said on the Cornamuck scheme that the
draft orders would be published in March 2015
(similar to what he said in June 2014, see
previous update). The total cost of Cornamuck is
given as £5m, again information we already knew.
He also mentioned the Kilgortnaleague
scheme where he said that early design work is
underway. This has been the position since 2010,
so that doesn't really represent much change.
However, he did say that he hoped to announce
the preferred corridor "in 2015" and for the
first time gave a cost estimate, which is £6m.
He did not mention the Esker Bog or New
Park schemes. The overall impression is
that this set of schemes is not a high priority,
and it doesn't look to me as if any of the four
oustanding schemes will happen in the near
future.
19 Jun 2014: According to the recent DRD
Roads Service report
to Omagh District Council the draft legal
orders for Cornamuck are due to be
published "in the coming year". Progress seems
to be slow on this one, since it's now over two
years since the Stage 2 report was approved.
Perhaps money is the issue. The document also
says that design work is underway on Kilgortnaleague,
although since this was also the case in the
2010 Omagh council report (see update below for
30 Dec 2010) it indicates little progress. The
report makes no reference to Esker Bog,
even though it seemed more advanced in the last
update in April 2013 (below). Finally, there is
no mention of the proposed upgrade to the bad
bends at New Park, so I'm not sure if
anything is still planned here. So it doesn't
look as if we can expect to see much happening
on the A32 in the next year or two.
24 Apr 2013: The Roads
Service web site is now saying that the
Stage 2 report for the Esker Bog scheme
was approved on 27 February 2013. This at least
indicates that design work is proceeding, but
there is still no indication when the remaining
four schemes on the A32 will be constructed.
13 Feb 2013: Today the "Roads"
Minister officially
opened the Shannaragh scheme,
which has been ongoing since last March. This is
a month ahead of the expected completion date as
announced last year, so well done to the
contractor (Coffey Construction/White Mountain).
The final cost is confirmed to be £7.3m. This
scheme was the third of the planned upgrades to
the A32, but the most expensive and largest of
those carried out to date. In total 2.2km of new
road has been built. The Impartial
Reporter contains a photograph of the
Minister with two people, presumably
contractors, at the opening. They appear to be
standing on the "new" Shannaragh Bridge, which
lies a few metres east of the
original bridge, which has been (or will
be) removed as part of the road realignment.
There are also three photos of the work (taken
last September) on
Flickr which gives you an idea of the
scale of this scheme.
4 Jan 2013: There was an excellent
article on this set of schemes in the
most recent issue (page 45-46) of Plant
and Civil Engineer magazine. The article
explains some of the background to the
proposals, and what has been achieved so far. It
also notes that with pressures on budgets, only
Shannaragh and Drumskinny were
deliverable in the short term (the former is
underway, and the latter completed). The Mullaghbane
scheme was completed in 2009. The article
suggests that Cornamuck and Esker
Bog will be next. This just leaves the New
Park and Kilgortnaleague schemes
on the long finger. The article mentions the Sidare
scheme, but does not mention that this scheme
was apparently cancelled two years ago (see
update on 10 Dec 2010 below). The article also
includes a couple of nice images of the
Shannaragh scheme underway, including one of the
new bridge over the Owenreagh River that is
required. The Shannaragh scheme still seems to
be on schedule for completion in March 2013. It
looks as if delivery of all seven elements of
the A32 improvements could be some years away.
2 July 2012:
The recently published report to Omagh
District Council contained pictures of two
current/completed schemes. The first photo shows
the Drumskinny
scheme which was completed in March 2012. The
second shows early earthworks underway at Shannaragh,
which began in March 2012 and will be ongoing
until March 2013. The report also seems to
confirm that Esker
Bog and Drumskinny are in fact separate
schemes, which explains the puzzlement in the
previous update, and suggesting that Esker Bog
is a future scheme.
The completed scheme at Drumskinny, circa March
2012. [Roads Service image from here]
Earthworks
underway at Shannaragh sometime during or before
June 2012.
[Roads Service image from here]
6 April 2012:
I have not been in the area to check, but I am
assuming that the Esker Bog/Drumskinny scheme has
now been completed as it was timetabled to be
finished last month. According to the Roads
Service web
site the Stage 2 report for the Cormamuck
scheme was approved on 13 March 2012 with a cost
of £5m-6.5m. This time last year (see below) the
Minister said that the preferred option for
Cornamuck would be published in late 2011, but
so far nothing has appeared. (The Roads Service
web site now says that the Stage 1 report for
Esker Bog/Drumskinny was also approved on 13
March 2012. This makes little sense as that
scheme is now completed, unless there is further
confusion about whether this is made up of one
or two schemes.) Work on the Shannaragh
scheme appears to be ongoing.
3 Mar 2012: A
press
release issued on Thursday confirmed what
we knew last month, ie that the contract for the
Shannaragh
scheme has been awarded, but added that work
would be beginning on Monday, 5th March and be
completed "by March 2013". It confirms that the
total cost of the scheme is £7.3m, of which the
value of this construction contract is £4.3m.
This makes it the most expensive of the A32
scheme family to date, mainly because it is also
the largest.
10 Feb 2012:
The contract to carry out the Shannaragh scheme
was awarded to Whitemountain
Quarries Ltd / Coffey Construction Ltd Joint
Venture on 27th January 2012. If work
has not already started, it is likely to do so
soon. This is slightly later than was
anticipated last summer. There is no word on the
remaining three elements of the A32 upgrade
programme, namely Cornamuck, New Park and
Kilgortnaleague which are still at an early
stage of development.
21 Sep 2011: The contract to carry out the Drumskinny
scheme was awarded
to Fox
Building & Engineering Ltd on
31st August, and a press
release was issued today confirming
that work is commencing. The same press
release confirmed that the total cost of the
Drumskinny scheme is now £1.8m, of which the
construction contract represents £1m. The
scheme will see almost 1 km of the A32
realigned and straightened to improve road
safety. The completion date is given as
"March 2012", ie around 6 months' duration.
4 Jul 2011: The Minister has
given another update on this scheme via a Written
Answer in the Assembly. Drumskinny
is now due to get underway in September this
year, while Shannaragh is
unchanged with commencement still due in
December. Cornamuck is still a
"priority" but the implication is that there is
not currently enough money to built it.
5 Jun 2011: The Drumskinny
scheme is currently out
to tender with a closing date of 16th
June, while the Shannaragh
scheme was
out to tender during May. In a press
release, Roads Service confirm that work
on Shannaragh is due to begin in December this
year with completion "in 2012", while Drumskinny
will be completed "before the end of the current
financial year", which presumably means by April
2012. The tender document states that the work
will begin in "late August". Last month a serious
road accident occured at Shannaragh, at
one of the bad bends due to be removed by the
scheme there. While we do not know whether the
road alignment was a factor in this accident, it
does nevertheless highlight the value of
upgrading the A32.
25 Apr 2011: Due to the
deteriorating financial climate, there is
uncertainty over when the five remaining
elements of this scheme will be constructed. In
a Question
for Written Answer last month, the
Minister said draft orders for the Shannaragh
scheme (the most imminent one) have now been
published. He also said that the "preferred
option" for Cornamuck (ie the
design Roads Service would like to build) will
be published "later this year". However, the
Minister could not give any firm committment to
progress with any of the schemes within a
specific timeframe. The design documents for
Shannaragh are on the DRD web site,
but they don't seem to be listed anywhere. You
can find them by going to this
page and typing "Shannaragh" into the
search box. Meanwhile, the tender
for construction of the Shannaragh scheme was
advertised on 12th April and will close on 25th
May. This is earlier than expected, based on the
information we had in December (see below). The
Roads Service web site is
also saying that the Drumskinny scheme may
go to tender in May 2011.
7 Mar 2011: Roads Service have
provided some more information on the progress
on these schemes via a Question
for Written Answer. It confirms what we
already knew about the progress and gives new
cost estimates - Shannaragh is now £7m (down
from £8m in December), Cornamuck is £5.1m, and
Drumskinny/Esker Bog is £1.4m. This
press release issued on Friday suggests
that some new money has been made available
which may help some or all of these schemes to
progress.
30 Dec 2010:
Some clarity at last on the various schemes (see
previous update) has come by scouring council
reports from earlier in the year. Part of what I
have found is a more up-to-date map by Roads
Service showing the various schemes. I have
included this map above. An update on each
scheme is given below based on the Fermanagh
and Omagh
council reports from Spring 2010 as well as this
more recent press release on the subject.
On the basis of this new information I have
re-written the text above to reflect the current
position.
- The Mullaghbane scheme no
longer appears in Roads Service documents,
presumably because it was completed in 2009.
See here
for contract details.
- On the Shannaragh scheme,
the legal orders and environmental statement
are due to be published "in the coming weeks".
The contract is scheduled to be awarded "late
in the 2011/12 financial year", ie early 2012.
This scheme alone is estimated
to cost almost £8m.
- It seems that the Drumskinny
scheme is actually an extension of the Esker
Bog scheme, so they are being
treated as a single scheme. Advanced site
works took place early in 2010 with the main
contract due to be released in March 2011,
according to the Roads
Service web site.
- There is no new information on the Cornamuck
or New Park schemes.
- The Sidaire scheme which
was to have been between Enniskillen and
Irvinestown has now been cancelled "due to
escalating costs associated primarily with
very poor ground conditions and the
necessity to acquire adjoining land and
property".
- Design work is underway on the Kilgortnaleague
scheme.
5 June 2010: According to this
press release, work on the Shannaragh
scheme is now expected to commence "in 2012",
which is a year later than anticipated in
November. Bizzarely, the press release also says
that the Mullaghbane scheme
"is nearing completion" despite the fact that a
press release issued
over a year ago claims the same thing!
Strange time warps on the A32... So far only one
of these eight associated schemes has been
carried out. This
press release notes that design work is
being carried out on the Kilgortnaleague
scheme at the Enniskillen end. The Sidaire
scheme is still on the Roads Service "future
tenders" list (release date Dec 2010), but the Esker
Bog scheme has inexplicably now
disappeared from the list. However, a new scheme
called "Drumskinny"
has now appeared (with a release planned for Sep
2010). This may be the same thing, or it may be
a nearby scheme previously referred to as Cornamuck.
Who knows? It is not helpful to the public if
Roads Service are changing the names of schemes
half way through the planning process!
23 January 2010: The Esker
Bog and Sidaire
schemes have appeared on Roads Service's "future
tenders" list. The tender for the Esker Bog
scheme is due to be released in August 2010,
while the Sidaire one is due to be released in
December 2010.
22 November 2009: This
press release from last week outlines the
current position on this scheme. The Esker
Bog scheme will apparently commence
"this financial year" subject to land acquision.
This presumably means by April 2010. The Sidaire
and Shannaragh schemes are
expected to commence in "early 2011" subject to
land acquisition and available funding. There
are no updates on the remaining four schemes.
7 June 2009: According to this
press release from about 3 weeks ago, the
scheme at Mullaghbane was
nearly completed while the scheme at Sidaire
may proceed "later this year if land acquisition
is successful". A public exhibition on the Shannaragh
scheme took place on 28 May 2009. The current
position, therefore, is that of the 8 schemes
planned for the A32, one is completed with seven
still to proceed.
11 Apr 2009: According to latest
information, the scheme at Mullaghbane
is actually underway now, with completion due in
May 2009. Work apparently began there in late
January and involves both carraigeway widening
and realignment over a distance of 0.7km. The
contractor is James Balfour & Sons Ltd. The
same information states that the scheme at Sidaire
is due to get underway next, likely by April
2010 (subject to acquisition of land) at a cost
of around £800,000. Information
on the Roads Service web site, meanwhile,
suggests that the tender for the Esker
Bog scheme will be released in Spring
2010. This suggests construction *might* happen
in 2011. The remaining schemes are described as
"a rolling programme" which we believe are to be
completed by 2015.
2 Mar 2009: The Regional
Development Minister answered a question in
Stormont on the timescale of these improvements.
In his
reply, the Minister confirmed that the
schemes would proceed separately, with only two
of them (at Esker Bog and Sidare) being planned
to open before the new hospital in Enniskillen
opens (currently planned for 2012). The reply
also mentions four of the other schemes which he
says will open after the hospital. The reply
makes no mention of the schemes at Drumbulcan
and Mullaghbane. It thus seems as if these
improvements will be provided over a period of
several years, rather than all at once in a
single contract. The reply also confirms that
the DRD is contributing £10m, and the Department
of Health £5m "to facilitate blue light
services on this stretch of road".
2 Feb 2009:
Over the past few months this scheme (or series
of schemes) has been moved into the preparation
pool, meaning that construction is anticipated
within the next five years. In November 2008 a
leaflet was issued about these proposals,
the wording of which suggests that the various
elements will be implemented separately, and
that some will involve building short stretches
of road offline. The leaflet gives the rationale
for the project as being to "reduce journey
times, provide a safer route and improve
journeys for Accident & Emergency services".
|